Joint Ventures: Why the Exit Matters as Much as the Entry

Introduction

When parties establish a Joint Venture (“JV“), they naturally focus on getting the business started: the business opportunity, capital contributions, shareholding structure, governance arrangements and the JV company’s operations.

One issue, however, is often overlooked at the outset: “How will the parties exit the JV if circumstances change?“

Business strategies and circumstances can change. The parties may develop different priorities, the JV may no longer achieve its original objectives, or the shareholders may reach a deadlock on significant matters.

For this reason, a well-structured JV should address not only how the parties will do business together, but also how they can part ways in an orderly manner if circumstances change.

Why Should an Exit Mechanism Be Considered from the Outset?

Without an agreed exit framework, a shareholder wishing to leave may find itself effectively locked in, particularly where there is no ready market for its shares or the shareholders’ agreement restricts transfers to third parties.

More importantly, if the parties wait until a problem arises before discussing an exit, they may have to negotiate the terms at precisely the time when their interests are no longer aligned.

An exit framework agreed at the outset can therefore provide greater certainty and reduce the scope for later disputes.

What Exit Mechanisms Can Be Considered?

There is no one-size-fits-all exit mechanism. The appropriate arrangement will depend on the JV structure, the parties’ respective shareholdings and the circumstances in which an exit right should arise.

Common mechanisms include:

  1. Put options: allow a shareholder, upon specified events (such as a material breach, unresolved deadlock, or change of control), to require the other shareholder to purchase its shares, providing a direct route to exit the JV.
  1. Call options: allow a shareholder, upon specified events, to require the other shareholder to sell its shares, enabling one party to take full ownership of the JV.
  1. Deadlock buy-out mechanisms: provide a buy-sell process where the parties are unable to resolve a deadlock on fundamental matters, ultimately allowing one shareholder to acquire the other’s interest.
  1. Agreed sale mechanisms: provide a framework for the shareholders to sell their interests in the JV to a third party in specified circumstances.
  1. Dissolution and winding-up mechanisms: provide an ultimate exit where the JV can no longer continue, its original commercial purpose can no longer be achieved, or legal or regulatory developments make its continued operation impracticable.

The parties may also consider share transfer arrangements, such as rights of first refusal, rights of first offer, and tag-along or drag-along rights. These do not necessarily provide a direct right to exit, but they can facilitate and regulate the exit process where a shareholder proposes to sell its shares.

The right mechanism will depend on the commercial dynamics of each JV, including the parties’ shareholdings, bargaining positions, financial resources and longer-term objectives.

The Mechanics Matter

An exit right on paper is not enough; the parties should also consider how it will work in practice.

Key considerations include:

  1. the events that trigger the exit mechanism;
  2. how the share value will be determined and by whom;
  3. the timeframe and payment terms;
  4. the treatment of shareholder loans, guarantees and other continuing liabilities; and
  5. the steps required to complete the exit.

For example, a buy-out mechanism may be difficult to implement if the agreement does not clearly establish how the price will be determined or how the exit process will be completed. Exit mechanisms should therefore be designed for both legal enforceability and practical implementation.

Key Takeaways

Planning for an exit does not mean planning for failure. It means being prepared for change. Agreeing on a clear exit framework while the parties’ interests are still aligned can avoid uncertainty and difficult negotiations later.

A well-designed JV arrangement should therefore answer three fundamental questions:

  1. How will we enter the JV?
  2. How will we operate it together?
  3. How will we exit if circumstances change?

Considering the exit from the beginning can help create a more resilient JV and give the parties greater clarity and certainty throughout its life.

If you have any queries on the above, please reach out to our Partner listed on this page.

For regional Mergers and Acquisitions, and Corporate and Commercial matters, please contact Rajah & Tann Asia’s Mergers & Acquisitions Practice and Corporate & Commercial Practice for more information.

Contribution Note:

This Legal Update is contributed by the listed Contact Partner, with the assistance of Senior Associate Nalanta Tonghorm and Associate Tatpicha Phokeeratikul.


 

Disclaimer

Rajah & Tann Asia is a network of member firms with local legal practices in Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. Our Asian network also includes our regional office in China as well as regional desks focused on Brunei, Japan and South Asia. Member firms are independently constituted and regulated in accordance with relevant local requirements.

The contents of this publication are owned by Rajah & Tann Asia together with each of its member firms and are subject to all relevant protection (including but not limited to copyright protection) under the laws of each of the countries where the member firm operates and, through international treaties, other countries. No part of this publication may be reproduced, licensed, sold, published, transmitted, modified, adapted, publicly displayed, broadcast (including storage in any medium by electronic means whether or not transiently for any purpose save as permitted herein) without the prior written permission of Rajah & Tann Asia or its respective member firms.

Please note also that whilst the information in this publication is correct to the best of our knowledge and belief at the time of writing, it is only intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter and should not be treated as legal advice or a substitute for specific professional advice for any particular course of action as such information may not suit your specific business and operational requirements. You should seek legal advice for your specific situation. In addition, the information in this publication does not create any relationship, whether legally binding or otherwise. Rajah & Tann Asia and its member firms do not accept, and fully disclaim, responsibility for any loss or damage which may result from accessing or relying on the information in this publication.

CONTACTS

Thailand,
+66 2656 1991

Country

Share