In Farzin Ratan Karma v Helen Campos & 2 Ors [2024] SGHC 41, which centred on issues of conflict in business relationships, the Singapore High Court had to determine a claim for commercially unfair and oppressive acts, as well as a counterclaim for breach of fiduciary duties owed as director.
The Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant were shareholders in the 2nd and 3rd Defendant companies. The Plaintiff claimed that the 1st Defendant had perpetrated various commercially unfair and oppressive acts against him with regard to the companies. The Court dismissed the Plaintiff’s claim, rejecting the following acts as being forms of oppression, and finding that they were not unreasonable or commercially unfair to the Plaintiff:
(a) The 1st Defendant’s drawing of salaries;
(b) The alleged diversion of business by the 1st Defendant to a third-party company; and
(c) Rights issues that had been conducted in relation to the 2nd and 3rd Defendants.
The Defendants counterclaimed against the Plaintiff for breach of his fiduciary duties as director of the 2nd and 3rd Defendants. The Court allowed part of the counterclaim, finding as follows:
(a) The Plaintiff had breached the no-conflict rule by causing the 2nd Defendant to enter into an agreement with his personal company for an employee of the 2nd Defendant to do his personal company’s work in exchange for a monthly sum, which in fact was not paid for a number of months; and
(b) The Plaintiff had used his position as the 2nd Defendant’s bank signatory to incur substantial personal expenses.
The Defendants were successfully represented by Vikram Nair and Ashwin Kumar Menon from the Commercial Litigation Practice.
Disclaimer
Rajah & Tann Asia is a network of member firms with local legal practices in Cambodia, Indonesia, Lao PDR, Malaysia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Singapore, Thailand and Vietnam. Our Asian network also includes our regional office in China as well as regional desks focused on Brunei, Japan and South Asia. Member firms are independently constituted and regulated in accordance with relevant local requirements.
The contents of this publication are owned by Rajah & Tann Asia together with each of its member firms and are subject to all relevant protection (including but not limited to copyright protection) under the laws of each of the countries where the member firm operates and, through international treaties, other countries. No part of this publication may be reproduced, licensed, sold, published, transmitted, modified, adapted, publicly displayed, broadcast (including storage in any medium by electronic means whether or not transiently for any purpose save as permitted herein) without the prior written permission of Rajah & Tann Asia or its respective member firms.
Please note also that whilst the information in this publication is correct to the best of our knowledge and belief at the time of writing, it is only intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter and should not be treated as legal advice or a substitute for specific professional advice for any particular course of action as such information may not suit your specific business and operational requirements. You should seek legal advice for your specific situation. In addition, the information in this publication does not create any relationship, whether legally binding or otherwise. Rajah & Tann Asia and its member firms do not accept, and fully disclaim, responsibility for any loss or damage which may result from accessing or relying on the information in this publication.
